Anybody past the age of 10 undoubtedly has said or done something at one time or another in their life that, looking back, causes them shame. What gets me is that sometimes people who were raised in a particular culture can be terribly unforgiving of someone raised in another culture. In the South, prior to Wallace’s school-house-door-stand, our way of life was not just a way of life but so deeply ingrained that reactions to stimuli were done without blinking, much less thinking, about why we did what we did, or said what we said.
In one of our treasured few alone times, Dad had told me about his upbringing in rural Alabama. He was not a bad man, by any stretch of the imagination, but he said there were things in his past that he deeply regretted, particularly the way he, as a teenager, had interacted with “persons of color.” He very carefully described to me how his actions, upon reflection, caused him mental anguish, and I took it all to heart, especially when he told me that the color of a person’s skin had nothing to do with the color of their heart, and that the black race was not the Mark of Cain, but an environmental evolution. Unfortunately, Mom did not share those opinions in their entirety. Having been a servant/slave herself, I understood why the chalk on our back fence meant transients could safely knock on our door and get a handout, that we had charity for those in less fortunate circumstances. The charity, however, did not extend to everyone. When I was twelve, she commented about the black gentleman going through our trash can in the alley, and told me to demand he leave. I responded with the sure and certain fact that there was nothing wrong with what he was doing, that he deserved a chance. She was incensed at my temerity, and demanded again I tell him to leave. My refusal to obey was accompanied by the further thought that I didn’t understand her, as she was no better than that man. Through livid lips she sent me into exile. When brother came home, he noticed, and asked, “What did she do this time?” Mom’s answer did not exactly sit well with Bro, and he tried to defend me, saying “Well, you know, that’s what they’re teaching in school these days.” Being politically correct was not an acceptable excuse. When Dad got home, her lecture to him about his daughter’s disrespect resulted in the last time he ever raised his hand to me, but with each lash, I saw his tears, and I knew the whipping really did hurt him more than it hurt me. I came to understand that it was not so much what I had said to Mom but the way I had said it.
A few days later, Dad commented, in a quiet aside, “You know, most people would actually rather have a hand up than a hand out.” I knew what he meant, having seen his equal opportunity employment practices in action way before the rest of the chamber of commerce caught up. I think it was only natural that when an article about the deplorable conditions in 60’s Birmingham appeared in Life magazine, I wrote a letter to the editor. Surprisingly enough, considering my age, they considered it for publication. But, also because of my age, I suspect, they sent a letter giving the schedule for when it would appear in print. Keep in mind, any mail coming to our house was opened prior to the recipient seeing it. “What did you write to them?” mom yelled! “I told her about the article I had seen in the magazine in the school library, and said my response was a firsthand agreement with their take on current race relations in our fair city. You don’t even want to know the punishment I got about that particular disgrace. Mom said "somebody" would burn a cross on our lawn. Dad was more worried "somebody" would burn down our house. A quick telegram to the publishers resulted in the letter getting into print but credited to an anonymous source (yes, they could do that back in those days). I kept the letter and that particular edition of the magazine for years, knowing that in my heart I was right. I also learned that no matter the intent, sometimes actions have repercussions transcending a good heart. For the remainder of the years I lived in that house, I walked in two worlds, the one outside our home and the one inside the walls.
Fast forward fourteen years. One fine morning in Basic Training, the instructor of the hour said, “OK, all of you who are colored stand up.” Six black sisters and I rose to our feet. The incredulous sniggers from a couple of them was quickly quieted, however, when the instructor then said, “OK, all of you who are transparent stand up.” The seven of us were told to sit down. And then the instructor said, “OK, let’s try it again. All of you who are colored stand up.” Everyone in the room immediately rose.
So where’s this all leading? Sometimes it’s better to stand up and be heard, but other times it’s better to sit down and be quiet. Paula, Paula, Paula, you shoulda quit while you were ahead.